30 Benmore Crescent

Find out about the consents for 30 Benmore Crescent.

Update Benmore Consnet (29/10/2026)

Further to Council’s ongoing processing of the above notified resource consent application, and following review of the application material, submissions received, and post‑notification technical input, Council requires further information under section 92 of the RMA to enable a full and informed assessment of the proposal and its effects.

The matters for which further information is required are set out below. The request is post‑notification in nature and is intended to consolidate, clarify, and refine the information relied upon for determination of the application, rather than to reopen or re‑scope the proposal.

Request for Further Information (s92 RMA)

  1. Consolidated Post‑Notification Information Package

Please provide a single, consolidated application package that brings together all relevant and current material relied upon for assessment of the proposal. The package must be capable of being read and relied upon as a complete, standalone source, without reference to superseded or fragmented documents. This request is post‑notification in nature and is not intended to reopen or re‑scope the application, but to consolidate, clarify, and refine the proposal and its assessment.  It should include:

  1. Updated AEE and Supporting Information - Please provide an updated AEE that:
  • Reflects the proposal as it now stands following notification
  • Integrates all relevant supporting technical assessments relied upon by the applicant (noting these should be updated where relevant)
  • Includes any updated draft management plans
  • Addresses matters raised through submissions and post‑notification review.

The AEE should be structured so that it can be readily understood without needing to cross‑reference multiple historic documents. Outdated, superseded or partially relied‑upon material should be clearly identified and excluded from reliance.

  1. Updated Plans and Drawings - Please provide a complete and consistent set of current plans and drawings that:
  • Accurately reflect the proposal including identifying any changes made since the original lodgement or notification of the application
  • Are consistent with the updated AEE and assessments
  • Are clearly dated, version‑controlled, and referenced.
  1. Covering Statement – Post‑Notification Changes - Please provide a concise covering statement that:
  • Identifies the key changes, refinements, or confirmations made since notification
  • Summarises any changes made in response to matters raised in submissions, or engagement with submitters
  • Explains how the consolidated package should be read as a single, integrated information set.
  • Please provide written confirmation of agreement with third party landowner(s) where mitigation planting is proposed, confirming agreement for planting. Clarification should also be clearly stated as to who will be responsible for long-term maintenance where planting is proposed for mitigation purposes.
  1. Response to Submissions - Please provide a brief summary identifying:
  • Any changes to the proposal, mitigation, or assessment made in response to submission themes
  • Where no changes have been made, a short explanation of the applicant’s position.
  1. Draft Conditions of Consent - Please provide a comprehensive and reasonably developed set of draft consent conditions that the applicant proposes would apply if consent were granted. The draft conditions should:
    • Address the full range of potential effects associated with the proposal, including (but not limited to):
      noise, odour, dust, traffic, operational hours, lighting, visual amenity, fire risk and emergency management, waste handling and storage, pest management, monitoring and reporting, and effects on residential and recreational amenity;
    • Be expressed in clear, specific, and enforceable terms, rather than headings or high‑level statements of intent;
    • Include appropriate standards, management plans, monitoring, reporting, review, and compliance mechanisms where relevant; and
    • Reflect the refined post‑notification proposal and matters raised in submissions and technical review.

    Draft conditions are requested to enable decision‑makers and submitters to meaningfully understand how effects would be avoided, remedied, or mitigated in practice, consistent with accepted RMA and Environment Court practice for notified applications.

  2. Social and Community Effects

No Social Impact Assessment (SIA) was undertaken by the applicant. In response to submissions, Council has commissioned a review of the application by Jo Healy of Beca to consider potential gaps in the assessment of social and community effects. While a standalone SIA is not strictly required, the review identifies that a more fulsome assessment of community impacts is necessary. The proximity of this facility to surrounding residential properties is somewhat unique, and accordingly your assessment upon the receiving population should be strengthened.

In terms of impact from onsite activities, the noise assessment focuses on predicted noise levels but provides insufficient consideration of the characteristics of noise or the effects of a change in noise type on how people use recreational areas and private outdoor spaces, particularly within approximately 250 metres of the site. Further information is required on the cumulative effects of the proposal, including how multiple effects may interact spatially and temporally to affect residential amenity, recreation, and sensitive receivers.

Given the proposed operating hours, including weekend operations, and the nature of activities proposed, there is potential for effects on residential amenity to be exacerbated. Further assessment is required in the AEE of the combined effects of noise and odour on the use and enjoyment of outdoor spaces. It’s noted that the Manor Park Private Hospital has not been specifically assessed. Given the highly sensitive nature of the facility and its residents, and its proximity to the site (approximately 650 metres), further consideration is required of potential noise and odour effects, including the rationale for any exclusion from assessment. Engagement with facility operators would assist in determining whether there are potential social or amenity effects requiring further consideration.

  1. Receiving Environment - Please provide further information describing and assessing the receiving social environment for the proposal. This should identify residential communities, sensitive institutions, and recreational assets within the area of influence, and describe how these areas are used (including timing, duration, and sensitivity), rather than proximity alone.
  2. Residential Amenity - Please provide an integrated assessment of potential effects on residential amenity, including effects on the use and enjoyment of private outdoor spaces. This assessment should consider the cumulative effects of noise (including timing and character), odour, dust, visual change, pests, lighting, and hours of operation, including how these effects may combine over different times of day and across weekdays and weekends having regard to the close separation distance to residential properties.
  3. Recreational Amenity - Please provide an assessment of effects on recreational and community facilities where users may spend extended periods of time, including the Manor Park Playground, Hutt River Trail, and Te Awa Kairangi / Hutt River recreation areas. The assessment should address how combined noise and odour effects may affect user experience and amenity (particularly for local regular users).
  4. Odour Effects (Land‑Use Context) - Please provide further assessment of odour effects in terms of amenity, way of life, and wellbeing, in addition to any assessment undertaken for regulatory compliance purposes. This should include consideration of odour frequency, offensiveness, weekend operations, and effects on use of private and public outdoor spaces.
  5. Noise – Early Morning and Sleep Disturbance - Please extend the noise assessment to consider potential effects from early‑morning and night‑time operations, including potential sleep disturbance and the change in type or character of noise, rather than compliance with noise limits alone.
  6. Fire Risk and Community Safety - Please provide further information responding to Fire and Emergency New Zealand comments and submissions, including assessment of the potential social and wellbeing implications of fire risk. This should address community safety, smoke exposure, emergency response, and potential effects on nearby sensitive receivers.
  7. Operational Controls and Mitigation - Please provide further information demonstrating that proposed operational mitigation measures (including odour management, waste handling, waste covering and inspection procedures) are practicable, enforceable, and likely to be effective in practice, including during weekends and peak operational periods.
  8. Community Engagement - Please provide information on consultation undertaken with the surrounding community (or consultation proposed since lodgement), including a summary of issues raised and how those issues have informed the proposal, mitigation measures, or proposed consent conditions.
  9. Monitoring, Reporting, and Review - Please provide further details of the proposed monitoring and reporting framework for effects relevant to community amenity and wellbeing, including noise, odour, dust, traffic, fire incidents, and pest management. This should include reporting mechanisms, community access to information, and trigger and response processes for management of specific effects, or review of consent conditions, should effects exceed anticipated levels.
  10. Cumulative effects - Please provide an integrated assessment of the cumulative effects of the proposal, including where relevant how noise, odour, traffic, operating hours, and visual effects may combine over time to affect residential amenity, recreational use, and sensitive receivers. This assessment should consider both day‑to‑day operations and peak or atypical operational scenarios.
  11. Landscape and Visual Effects (Landscape Architecture)

Further information is required to clarify and substantiate the proposed landscape mitigation and visual integration of the development, particularly given the reliance placed on planting and river trail works to offset adverse visual and amenity effects.

  1. Internal Planting Details - Please provide detailed information on the planting proposed for internal planting areas shown on plan BM210903_600 and sheet 602, including species and grades, consistent with the level of detail provided for boundary screening and revegetation planting in the updated Appendix 4.
  2. Internal Planting Constraints - Please provide vehicle movement diagrams or equivalent information demonstrating required hardstand and manoeuvring areas within the site, and how these constrain the extent and effectiveness of internal planting. This should clarify the contribution internal planting can reasonably make to building integration when viewed from beyond the site.
  3. Updated Photosimulations - Please provide updated photosimulations from the identified viewpoints in the updated Appendix 4, prepared in accordance with NZILA best‑practice guidance (two‑page spread format). Photosimulations should include all proposed planting within the site and the proposed river trail works (or at least those works to be undertaken by the applicant, as shown on the relevant plans), to accurately represent the full horizontal field of view.
  4. Pedestrian Access and Dry Creek Planting - Please clarify the proposed pedestrian access off Benmore Crescent and along Dry Creek, which is identified for revegetation and riparian planting in the proposed landscape plans. This clarification should include whether there is potential for planting and continuous pedestrian access along the remaining extent of Dry Creek (outside the site), connecting from Benmore Crescent to the river trails.
  5. Certainty of Landscape Mitigation - Given the reliance on planted areas and river trail improvements as mitigation, please provide clarification and evidence as to how these works are secured through the suite of environmental management plans (refer AEE section 4.11), and how they are distinguished from establishment and maintenance provisions (refer suggested condition AEE 6.6).
  6. Consolidated Planting Plan - Please provide an overall planting plan with consistent plant schedules that integrates boundary planting, internal planting, and river trail works, to clearly show the extent of proposed mitigation and avoid reliance on multiple separate plan sets.
  7. Transport and Traffic Effects

Further information is required to clarify transport effects, confirm the basis of the traffic assessment, and ensure that relevant agency views are appropriately reflected.

  1. Engagement with NZTA Waka Kotahi - Please provide an update on engagement undertaken with NZTA Waka Kotahi since the close of submissions, including confirmation of any matters agreed in principle and the current position in respect of proposed conditions of consent.
  2. SIDRA Modelling - Please provide the full set of SIDRA modelling files for all scenarios assessed. This should include modelling for the Manor Park Road / Benmore Crescent intersection and the interchange, and confirmation of whether the full interchange has been modelled or only specific approaches.
  3. Vehicle Tracking - Please provide vehicle tracking drawings for all relevant vehicle types, showing movements in both directions along Benmore Crescent and Manor Park Road, to demonstrate the ability of the road network to safely accommodate the proposed vehicle movements.
  4. Noise

    Further information is required to clarify noise effects and to strengthen the assessment of potential impacts on amenity and wellbeing.

    Provide an updated expert noise assessment that:

    • Correctly identifies and addresses any instances or potential for non‑compliance with relevant noise standards; and
    • Provides an effects assessment that goes beyond numerical compliance, including consideration of the character, timing, and duration of noise.

    In preparing the updated assessment, please specifically address matters identified under Social and Community Effects, including the potential effects of early‑morning and weekend operations, changes in noise type, and the implications of noise for the use and enjoyment of recreational areas and private outdoor spaces, particularly for sensitive receivers and residential properties in close proximity to the site.

  5. Terrestrial Ecology (Indirect Effects)

    Submitters have raised concerns regarding potential ecological effects associated with the proposal. Further information is therefore required to clarify whether the proposal may give rise to adverse terrestrial ecological effects, particularly indirect effects resulting from lighting, noise, and operational activity.

    Please provide further expert assessment that:

    • Identifies whether terrestrial fauna (including birds, bats, and other noise or light‑sensitive species) are present or likely to utilise habitats within or adjacent to the site, including along the river corridor and riparian areas;
    • Assesses the potential effects of operational noise, night‑time lighting, and extended hours of activity on terrestrial fauna, including disturbance, displacement, or behavioural changes;
    • Addresses whether the scale, intensity, and duration of these effects could give rise to more than minor ecological effects, including cumulative effects over time; and
    • Identifies any additional mitigation or management measures required to avoid, remedy, or mitigate adverse terrestrial ecological effects (for example, lighting design, curfews, noise controls, or seasonal restrictions), or provides a clear rationale where no further mitigation is proposed.
  6. Hazardous Substances and Flood Risk

Submitters have raised concerns regarding the storage and management of hazardous substances on the site, having regard to the site’s proximity to the river environment. Please provide further information identifying the types and locations of hazardous substances proposed to be stored or used on site, the flood risk profile relied upon for their storage (including the effect of site raising), and the proposed containment, spill prevention, and emergency management measures to ensure that flood or extreme weather events would not result in the release or mobilisation of hazardous substances to the receiving environment.

The information requested is necessary to ensure that the proposal and its effects can be properly understood, assessed, and addressed, including by submitters and decision‑makers, on the basis of a single, coherent, and up‑to‑date information set. Please ensure that any updated material is internally consistent and clearly cross‑referenced.


The site at 30 Benmore Crescent, Manor Park has historically remained an undeveloped area comprising abandoned buildings, large grassed areas, and limited recreation amenities such as walking and cycling tracks. It was also previously utilised as a site for agricultural production, and the site of housing for railway workers during the construction of the Wairarapa Rail Line. Per the Operative District plan, this site is zoned 'General Rural'.

Hutt City Council (HCC) has received four resource consent applications relating to the development of the site at 30 Benmore Crescent, Manor Park (henceforth referred to as 'the site').

Resource Consent Compliance

A record of resource consent monitoring and enforcement for this site, including links to the relevant reports, can be found here.
The weekly vibration monitoring reports are available here.

You can contact HCC’s resource consent compliance team via enforcement@huttcity.govt.nz. The consent holder (Rosco Ice Cream Limited) can also be contacted directly via Richard Burrell at richard@building-solutions.co.nz or 029 244 1913.

This consent relates to a subdivision consent for a 125-year lease over a 7.4541ha area at 30 Benmore Crescent, as seen in the figure below.

Subdivision Site at 30 Benmore Crescent

Council commenced processing of this consent on the 22nd of April 2025, and no decision has been made regarding notification or approval. A request for further information (also known as a s92(1) request) was made on the 16th of June 2025. The request for further information related to updated assessment against the NES-Contaminated Soil, site management plans, compliance with relevant rules, conditions and clarification around information provided within the AEE.

As of March 2026, the application was withdrawn by the applicant's request and consent for this activity is no longer being sought.

The application documents can be found here:

  1. Assessment of Environmental Effects
  2. Scheme Plan
  3. Geotechnical Assessment Report
  4. Detailed Environmental Site Investigation

This consent relates to a land use consent for bulk earthworks and construction of a site office premises.

This consent was received by Council on the 1st of August 2022 and was subsequently granted on the 21st of December 2022.

The resource consent decision and approved plans can be found here:

Need for resource consent

Rules under the Operative District Plan which triggered the need for consent included:

  • Rule 14H 2.1.(a) – the construction of a site office building which was located within 20m of the Wellington Fault Special Study Area; and
  • Rule 14I 2.2(a) – earthworks which exceeds permitted activity allowances for volume and depth.

Additionally, consent was also sought under the same application per the National Environmental Standard for Assessing and Managing Contaminants in Soil to Protect Human Health (NESCS) Regulations 2011 as below –

  • Regulation 10 – soil disturbance which cannot comply with Regulations 8 or 9, which satisfies conditions 10(2)(a) – (d)

The proposal was assessed as being a restricted discretionary activity under Rules 14H 2.1(a) and 14I 2.2(a) of the District Plan, and Regulation 10 of the NESCS.

As a restricted discretionary activity, this meant that Council could only assess, request information, and impose conditions relating to those matters to which discretion was restricted. These were:

  • Safe separation distance of buildings from the Wellington Fault
  • Earthworks effects, relating to amenity values, existing natural features and topography, historical or cultural significance, and natural hazards
  • Regarding NESCS consent –
    • The adequacy of the Detailed Site Investigation
    • The suitability of the piece of land for the proposed activity, given the amount and kind of soil contamination
    • The approach to the remediation or ongoing management of the piece of land
    • The adequacy of the site management plan or the site validation report or both
    • The transport, disposal, and tracking of soil and other materials taken away in the course of the activity
    • The requirement for and conditions of a financial bond
    • The timing and nature of the review of the conditions in the resource consent.
    • The consent duration

Assessment Process

In addition to core information requirements for resource consents as required under Schedule 4 of the Resource Management Act (RMA), the application submitted supporting technical assessments in relation to –

  • Archaeological effects
  • Soil contamination and management
  • Erosion and sediment control
  • Natural hazards – flooding
  • Natural hazards – geotechnical
  • Ecological effects

These were assessed by the HCC processing planner, with support from in-house subject matter experts. A site visit was undertaken, and further information was requested from the applicant to ensure HCC had all information needed to assess effects from the proposal within the scope of the assessment matters listed above.

HCC consequently determined that, when considering all mitigation measures proffered by the applicant, effects from the proposal were less than minor on the environment and on all persons eligible for consideration under s95E. This meant the consent was processed on a non-notified basis.

Effects were overall deemed acceptable under s104 of the RMA and consent was approved subject to resource consent conditions. A full list of these conditions can be found in Section 7 of the resource consent decision linked above.

Exclusions

The proposal successfully demonstrated compliance with HCC’s rules relating to –

  • Construction and demolition noise
  • Construction and demolition vibration
  • Traffic and vehicle movements
  • Vegetation clearance

Consequently, these activities did not require resource consent and are to be undertaken in accordance with District Plan rules. It is noted that the Operative District Plan anticipates and provides for some additional noise emissions throughout construction and demolition activities, in accordance with NZS 6803P "Measurement and Assessment of Noise from Construction, Maintenance and Demolition Work", however this generally limits working hours to between 7.30am – 5pm Monday – Saturday with the exception of site preparation works which may commence from 6.30am.

FAQ

  • I think I am affected by the development – why wasn’t I formally notified of this consent? A notification assessment is a legal decision undertaken in accordance with the requirements of the RMA.  When assessing whether any person will be affected by a proposal, Council must take into consideration factors such as separation distances, expected amenity outcomes based on surrounding activities and zoning, mitigation put forward by the applicant, and duration of an effect. For this consent, the processing planner determined that no persons would be affected by the proposal to a degree that met the test for formal notification.
  • Will the earthworks impact flooding to my property or surrounding areas? The development has been designed to contain all flood and stormwater effects internal to the site. A flood assessment report prepared by River Edge Consulting Limited demonstrated that the proposal will not result in flooding which will affect the wider community.
  • I am concerned about asbestos and other contaminants. Prior to lodgement of the consent, a Detailed Site Investigation was conducted and concluded that concentration of asbestos fibres and other contaminants were all below human health thresholds. Several controls have been put in place for the removal of contaminated soils and remediation of the site in accordance with WorkSafe and BRANZ guidelines.
  • I am concerned that the development is in breach of the District Plan or the consent conditions.  Regular site inspections and monitoring events will be taken to ensure compliance with resource consent conditions and the District Plan. If you suspect there is activity occurring which does not comply with the District Plan or the conditions of this consent RM220258 please contact enforcement@huttcity.govt.nz.
  • Who can I contact about this consent? For general enquiries, you can contact HCC’s resource consents team via resource.consents@huttcity.govt.nz or 0800 488 824. The consent holder (Rosco Ice Cream Limited) can also be contacted directly via Richard Burrell at richard@building-solutions.co.nz or 029 244 1913.

This consent relates to a land use consent for bulk earthworks for the construction of roading and civil infrastructure.

This consent was received by Council on the 10th of February 2023 and was subsequently granted on the 27th of January 2025.

The resource consent decision and approved plans can be found here:

Processing Information

The initial resource consent application and plans submitted for assessment can be found here: Application and Plans
Note that some parts of this application have been superseded by later amendments.

The s.92(1) request for further information and the s.92(2) request for technical review can be found here: s.92(1) & s.92(2) request

On the 11th of August 2023, Hutt City Council received the following information from the applicant:

Council had commissioned a peer review of the supplied traffic report.

The applicant also requested the application be placed on hold for consultation with both Waka Kotahi and Kiwirail.

On the 16th of October 2024, Hutt City Council received an amended application with an updated Assessment of Environmental Effects and updated plans, which can be found here:  Amended Application and Plans

On the 31st of October 2024, the New Zealand Transport Agency issued written approval for the proposal. We received this written approval letter on the 1st of November, 2024. You can view the document here:  NZTA Written Approval

On the 20th of November 2024, Kiwirail issued written approval for the proposal. You can view the document here: Kiwirail Written Approval
On the 27th of January 2025,  Hutt City Council granted approval for the consent. You can view the document here:  RM230018 Decision Report

Need for resource consent

Rules under the Operative District Plan which triggered the need for consent included:

  • Rule 14I 2.2(a) – earthworks which exceeds permitted activity allowances for volume and depth.
  • Rule 13.3.1.38 – The construction, alteration or diversions of roads, excluding any such construction works which is part of a subdivision.

Additionally, consent is also sought under the same application per the National Environmental Standard for Assessing and Managing Contaminants in Soil to Protect Human Health (NESCS) Regulations 2011 as below –

  • Regulation 9 – a change in use of a potentially contaminated site, which cannot meet Regulation 8 but satisfies the condition for a controlled activity under Regulation 9(3).

Consent has hence been sought as a restricted discretionary activity under Rule 14I 2.2(a) of the District Plan, a discretionary activity under Rule 13.3.1.38 of the District Plan and as a controlled activity under Regulation 9 of the NESCS.

Assessment Process

  • Processing of this consent is currently paused pending further information and for consultation with KiwiRail and Waka Kotahi as the relevant authorities for works within their designation areas.
  • Additional information has also been sought from the applicant to ensure HCC has sufficient information to correctly identify all non-compliances with the District Plan, and to assess effects of these on people and the environment.
  • Council’s development engineers will also be assessing the proposed infrastructure servicing arrangement and capacity, in conjunction with Wellington Water Limited.
  • Once all information is supplied HCC will follow the established legal process to determine whether the consent will be notified under s95 of the RMA, and whether it will be approved in accordance with s104 of the RMA.

Who can I contact about this consent?

  • For general enquiries, you can contact HCC’s resource consents team via resource.consents@huttcity.govt.nz or 0800 488 824.
  • The consent applicant (Rosco Ice Cream Limited) can also be contacted directly via Richard Burrell at richard@building-solutions.co.nz or 029 244 1913.

This relates to a land use consent for the construction of a resource recovery park. The resource recovery park will include the following activities on site:

  • Second-hand good store
  • Repair Café
  • Material Recovery Facility
  • Transfer Station

On the 23rd of October 2025, Hutt City Council issued the following notification decision report for the consent:

On the 14th of January 2026 Council publicly notified the application, with submissions open to any persons. The deadline for submissions closed at 5pm on 11th of March 2026. More information can be found here.

On the 11 February 2026, Waste Management New Zealand formally requested that the submission time be extended an additional 20 working days.  Council has agreed to this request, taking into account the relevant matters under Section 37A(1) of the RMA 1991.

On the 18th of March 2026, Waste Management New Zealand formally requested direct referral to the Environment Court under Section 87D of the RMA 1991:

On the 9th of April 2026, this direct referral request was granted by Council under Section 87E of the RMA 1991:

Greater Wellington Regional Council

Resource consent WGN230031 has been granted from Greater Wellington Regional Council (GWRC) for the proposed development. No other consents have been lodged with GWRC relating to this site. As a regional consenting authority, GWRC is responsible for assessing environmental effects relating, but not limited, to:

  • Bulk earthworks (greater than 0.3 hectares in area)
  • Vegetation clearance on erosion-prone land
  • Discharges to land, air and water
  • Water takes

HCC is liaising with GWRC to ensure that a complimentary approach to assessing and managing the development is taken where there is a cross-over in jurisdictional responsibility (for example, earthworks and odour effects). GWRC’s earthworks assessment focusses on effects relating to soil conservation, sedimentation of waterways, and ecological habitats, whereas HCC’s earthworks assessment relates more to amenity, cultural, historical, and natural hazard effects.

If the earthworks are not managed appropriately then sediment may enter the neighbouring stream and cause adverse environmental affects and damaging the health of the flora and fauna in the waterway.

For enquiries relating to consents being processed by GWRC for the development of the site, please contact info@gw.govt.nz or call 0800 496 734.


Contact

Email: resource.consents@huttcity.govt.nz

Phone:  +64 04 570 6666